Columbus, OH Pizza Delivery - Don Gino's Pizza

Don Gino's Pizza - Columbus, OH

Name: Don Gino's Pizza
Address: 5283 W Broad St, Columbus, OH, 40033, United States
Telephone: 614-878-7110
Price range: $

Order Online Call Us

Voted Best Pizza in Columbus, OH

Columbus Craves Don Gino’s: Voted Best Pizza in Town! Looking for the undisputed king of pizza in Columbus? Look no further than Don Gino’s Pizza! We’re proud to be Columbus’ voted-best pizza place, serving up mouthwatering pies made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. From classic pepperoni to gourmet creations, our menu has something to satisfy every pizza lover’s heart (and stomach!). We use only the finest cheeses and tastiest sauces, all on our signature, crispy crust. Don’t settle for just any pizza joint. Experience the Columbus favorite – Don Gino’s Pizza! Order online for delivery or carryout, or visit us and enjoy a slice of local legend.

Learn More About Us

See What our Customers Are Saying:

Rachel Vogel
10/27/2024

I was really, really impressed with this pizza! I've been telling EVERYONE. The sauce was FANTABULOUS,,, and the cheese?!

Jill Valaski
09/15/2024

I found Don Gino’s pizza when I moved to this area awhile ago & everytime I have ordered from them. They have been very friendly. They have also become one of my favorite pizza places! They are one of the only pizza places, that I know of in Columbus, other than Flyer’s pizza that have the crumbled Italian sausage. Which I love! You must try it!!!

suncheck
09/12/2024

News of the area this is my first time stopping in this pizza shop. I had a pepperoni and onion Pizza. The pizza was cooked just right. It was flavorful and had a very little grease but you would expect that from pepperoni. Why is very pleased and I will be going back. I want to try to some and also their wings.

Chris Danforth
08/30/2024

Got a DELICIOUS pizza and Italian sub today. First time customer, very impressed. My go-to pizza joint now 😎

Angel Rose
08/20/2024

I gave Don Gino’s Pizza a try for the first time. It did not disappoint. The food looked and tasted good. It was made exactly as I ordered. I’ll come back here again sometime.

terry mcCabe
06/30/2024

My neighbor has ordered DonGinos forever. I had never tried her pizza but man did I try the onion rings..I was sold. First I had never seen onion rings that large. They were piping hot, with lots of ketchup. *not kidding about the ketchup, I still have packs left over if they want it back!) My partner and I finally tried the pizza! It brought back memories of our favorite pizza joint on the south side of Chicago, where we moved from. It is now our "go to" anytime anyone discusses pizza or other Italian foods! They are not at all stingy with the toppings, it is (even delivered) almost too hot to dish out (great problem to have!) And we love our delivery driver..not sure of her name, but she is incredibly sweet and soooo nice.... We are forever Don Gino's pizza fans! BRAVO DON GINO'S!

Megan Roof
04/25/2024

Great pizza and portion sizes. Everything we ordered arrived perfectly. The sub was big enough to split and had all of the expected toppings for an Italian sub. The garlic sauce was very thick, but I didn’t mind it.

Tony Patrick
04/17/2024

Great cheese and toppings. I'm not a huge fan of the regular crust because it doesn't really have any flavor. Gonna try the thin crust next time we order. Philly was good, and the cheese sticks were great. I'll be back

Lisa Caldwell
04/05/2024

I have seen this place on line and tonight decided to try it. We absolutely love this pizza! Glad we tried it and would definitely recommend this pizza.

Derek Fraley
03/12/2024

My wife has ordered delivery from here twice with no issues, which is a good sign that they know what they're doing when it comes to that. I had ordered a ham, pepperoni, and banana pepper Stromboli. I thought for 18 dollars was kinda high until I saw how big it was. You could definitely get two meals out of it, which is what I did. I almost got a sub instead, but I'm glad I got the Stromboli. It was good, and they give you plenty of marinara on the side to dip it in. My wife ordered a pizza, and I didn't have any of it(my wife ordered toppings i dont like), but it is the kind where they put the cheese on top. Overall, the pizza looked good, and as long as you don't have anything against the cheese on top, I'd give that a try as well as the Stromboli.

Angel Rose
02/27/2024

I gave Don Gino’s Pizza a try for the first time. It did not disappoint. The food looked and tasted good. It was made exactly as I ordered. Luigi’s in Hilliard is still my favorite, but I’ll come back here again sometime.

Debra Porter
01/16/2024

I have loved this place since they opened over 9 years ago!! Their food is amazing, their prices are reasonable, the service is great!! They treat you like family!! They were also the first ones to volunteer to help me feed the football team at Westland High School! I was in charge of setting up dinner for the team! This was the favorite!!! They help a lot of other teams also. This is the best pizza place on the west side!!! Try them!! You’ll be back for more and their specials!!

Joan Snyder
11/18/2023

I love this place. There is nothing bad there. Love their pizza, Stromboli, Speghetti dinner, lasagna, subs, even their salad is good. Just wish they wouldn't have closed up the one on demorest. Or they'd open another one.

Katelyn Halter
09/30/2023

pizza is so good!! we got our order within 20 mins and it’s delicious every time. drivers are always really nice too!

Restaurant Critic
09/22/2023

Pizza was fantastic. We got it to go. It reminded me of pizza how it's supposed to be a little bit of grease. Great toppings the general and the cash just out was really pleasant but the food itself spoke for itself. I recommend it to anybody. If this was in a different area I'd be able to charge $25 a pizza and get away with it. Very inexpensive pizza and extremely great quality.

Elizabeth Chandler
09/18/2023

The owner of Don Gino’s is an upstanding person and it has been a pleasure working with him on a current project. Thank you sir for your support and time.

Danielle Johnson
09/11/2023

It's pick-up or delivery only...but food was awesome. Definitely a mom and Pop shop. I will be back.

Gabe Hinson
08/25/2023

Friendly, Wonderful place to order your best pizza 🍕 😋 from

Yorgelis Ramos
08/25/2023

Buenísimo

Dawn XX
07/25/2023

The pizza and Stromboli were delicious! Great, friendly service. This isn't a dine-in place, take out only but the best Stromboli I've ever had.

Barbette Pullins
07/25/2023

Little place on the west side Columbus!! I don’t eat cheese at all!! Only on pizza. It didn’t have the aftertaste I get from eating pizza! Delicious to the last bite!! We will be ordering as a treat twice a month for my family!!! Great job Guys!!

ty garrett
07/25/2023

It is a good pizza.

Barbette Pullins
07/10/2023

kenneth hutt
06/25/2023

Great as always

Edgar Villaruel
06/25/2023

Amazing Pizza 🍕 and Strombolis 🤤

ann azbell
05/25/2023

The best food 😋

Judy Labarge
05/25/2023

Their good.

Curtis J
04/25/2023

Best Stromboli I could ever even imagine.

Jon Anderson
04/25/2023

Yummy stromboli!

Bryan Smith
04/25/2023

Never been in, but we order a lot from there, fast and amazing food. Stromboli is huge! Pizzas amazing..

Julianna DeGroat-Träger
04/25/2023

Been over 20 years since I was here, it was called Antolinos and the New Rome Police were stilling gunning across the street. Very pleased to say that the name may have changed but the pizza and its quality have not. Delicious pizza and a large for less than $20. Thank you Don Gino.

Mika Hayes
03/25/2023

Best pizza and service on the Westside!!! Get the thick crust!

Dustin Albright
03/25/2023

Excellent all the way around.

Kimberly D
03/25/2023

Pizza here is delicious and so are the subs! This is classic "Columbus Style" square-cut pizza. It's the way I remember it growing up. They don't skimp on toppings and the sauce and crust are perfect!

Shawn Whalen
02/25/2023

Picked up a pizza not a bad atmosphere will definatly be back for more

zuly Matias
01/25/2023

The pizza is amazing here. Definitely going back

Kyriya
01/25/2023

Our first time ordering from Don Gino's and I'm so glad we did. We ordered a cheese and pepperoni, both with extra cheese. Absolutely amazing. The sauce isn't super sweet like a lot of the chain places, and extra cheese was really extra cheese. The pepperoni has a slight kick to it, which I love. And the crust was cooked to perfection. We had it delivered and it was hot and came quite quickly. Overall, very pleased and we will definitely be ordering again in the future.

Frank Busby
01/25/2023

Food is excellent! Pizza, subs, and wings! The only thing wrong is that they only don't open til 3pm! Even on Saturday game days!!!

Ricky Edwards
12/25/2022

I always like Don Ginos I feel like something has changed bit over the years like not putting as much oregano or basil or something in it as they used to. Which I thought kind of set it apart and made it what is is. Still good though.

Steve Baumgartner (SMB Computers)
12/25/2022

Yummy pizza

Eric Greber
12/25/2022

Best pizza on the west side. Parking: In and out

Amber Dishman
02/05/2021

My family and I tried Don Gino's pizza on West broad Street last night for the first time and we were all pleasantly surprised. Their sauce and cheese are the real standouts for us. Their sauce is not too sweet or tangy but actually taste like it was seasoned well with garlic and Italian seasoning, the cheese is so delicious and flavorful and they are not stingy with it .The thick crust dough on the pep and cheese was a little sweet which balanced out the sauce and we all really loved it. Their garlic cheesy bread was delicious and only half of that made it home. The wings were okay, we just prefer ours breaded and the fries were actually really good with the pizza. Staff was friendly and our pizza was ready for pickup on time Also their ranch is sooo delicious. We will for sure be back.

Our Favorite: Classic Pepperoni

Columbus’ Best Pepperoni? It’s a Don Gino’s Kinda Night! Calling all pepperoni pizza purists in Columbus! Craving that perfect slice with crispy crust, tangy sauce, and cups of delicious pepperoni? Don Gino’s Pizza is your answer! We’ve been voted Columbus’ best spot for pepperoni pizza, and it’s no surprise. We use only the freshest ingredients, from our signature sauce to the generous piles of premium pepperoni. Every bite is a symphony of flavor that will leave you wanting more. Skip the ordinary and experience Columbus’ pepperoni pizza legend – Don Gino’s! Order online for delivery or carryout, or visit us and see why we reign supreme.

Order Now

Locally Owned and Operated

About Us

5283 W Broad St
Columbus, OH 43228

614-878-7110

Order Now

Store Hours

Monday
- 03:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday
- 03:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday
- 03:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Thursday
- 03:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Friday
- 03:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Saturday
- 03:00 PM - 11:00 PM
- 12:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Sunday
- 03:00 PM - 10:00 PM

Columbus, OH Pizza Delivery

43228